This is actually a 4.5* rating. I don't know if it is because it has been a couple of months since I read the others or not, but I think this was my favorite so far. I wasn't crazy about Lore after book 3, so I wasn't sure if I was going to like this book, but reading his story, from his point of view, I really liked him. The way the story worked for Idess and her needing to protect Kynan was great. I have Sin Undone already requested from the library. I am excited to read the book, but sad that its the only book left to read in the series.